Login | Register
 
Message Board | Latest Posts | Your Recent Posts | Rules

Thread: Lord of the Rings the movie

Is this discussion interesting? Share it on Twitter!

Bottom of Page    Message Board > The Fellowship of the Ring > Lord of the Rings the movie   
Welcome to the forum Spartanswimr.

I don't believe that analogy came directly from Tolkien. In the Forward to the LOTR, Tolkien wrote.
Quote:
As for any inner meaning or 'postBody', it has in the intention of the postAuthorID none. It is neither allegorical nor topical.
Later on in this Forward, he mentioned that his experience in the two wars and the situation of England when he was finishing his tale had no influence on the story. And as far as any pre vs. post industrial Britain analogy goes, I believe he meant it only had a very slender basis experience-wise, because the country of his youth was already being shabbily destroyed.

I suggest that you read the forward yourself, and develop your own answer, as I may have it wrong. Others here, may have read some of his letters and can certainly provide you with a more knowledgeable answer. Cool Smilie
*stupid
Reading the forward, Grondy? lol. Think you meant the foreword... Big Smile Smilie

But he's right, Spartan. There is no analogy whatsoever. And you can believe this, cos JRR said so himself! Smile Smilie

Grondy says: Sometimes a spellchecker can't protect one from his own errors! Cool Smilie[Edited on 22/1/2002 by Grondmaster]
There always will be this misconception. I suppose the reason is how can somebody create a land and creatures, weave it into a book and was voted best novel and postAuthorID of the century.

Most writers that writes real well normally base their writings on their experience. If the book was an analogy of real things - the book will become so dull. Good books are made up of experience and creativity, with the percentage of 30:70.

Hello! Finally some sense in here! I definetely agree. (is that spelled right?) Big Smile Smilie A good book is fantastic and realistic in one. Smile Smilie