Login | Register
 
Message Board | Latest Posts | Your Recent Posts | Rules

Thread: Who and Why

Is this discussion interesting? Share it on Twitter!

Bottom of Page    Message Board > The Ivy Bush > Who and Why   [1] [2] [3] [4] >>
The rules of this are quite similar to where and why. All youhave to ask is what person you'd like to be in a place he/she was in sometime in their life. I'll start.

Felagund in Nargothrond
or
Galadriel in Menegroth?


who and why?
Felagund in Nargothrond, because it would be more exciting than sitting in a cave all day!

Durin in Moria
or
Thror in Erebor
Tricky, but Durin, because I never liked Erebor.

Boromir in Rivendell
or
Eomer in Rohan?


who and why!
eomer in rohan, his home, boromir didn't feel so fine among elves.

Frodo in Mordor
or
Beren in Angband (is that the name?)

Who and why?
Beren in Angband (yes it's the name) because he's got Luthien with him.

Melian in Doriath
or
Melian in Lorien
Melain in Lorien because 1. that was her home and 2. lorien is extremely beautiful

Gimli in Fangorn Forest
or
Legolas in the Glittering Caves
Who and Why?
Gimli in Fangorn. the air is more fresh there...all those trees, even grumpy ones would be good for the health... Cool Smilie

Treebeard in Fangorn
or
Galadriel in Lothlorien


who and why?
Galadriel in Lothlorien, because I think the atmosphere in Fangorn would be too oppressive.

Bilbo in Smaug's lair or Frodo in Shelob's lair
bilbo! me likes dragons and hates spiders... *urghhhh*

Strider in Bree
or
Aragorn in Minas Tirith
Aragorn in Minas Tirith, he is more kingly there.

Frodo in Rivendell
or
Frodo in Lothlorien
Who and Why?
Rivendell, it seems a lot more peaceful and less sorrowful there.

Samwise in the gardens of Bag End
or
Este tending the Two Trees of light?


who and why?
samwise in bag end...i think that samwise enjoys Bag End ALOT!!!!!

gandalf in Valinor
or
gandalf in middle-earth
Who and why?
Gandalf in Middle-earth. He didn't really have much to do in Valinor, now did he?

Eowyn in Edoras
or
Eomer in Gondor?
Eowyn in Edoras; I can't imagine Eomer thought much of the walled city (as impressive as it might appear) as he was raised among the wide open lands of Rohan

Merry in the Shire
or
Merry in Gondor?

Where and why?
Merry in Gondor, he had more to do and he seemed more noble in Gondor than in the Shire.

Sauron
or
Saruman
Who and Why?
Ooooooo, hard one, but I'd choose Sauron. He died a bit more impressively...

Sam
or
Frodo?
sam! I somehow don't quite like frodo very much... and sam is sooo noble... I really like his character.

shelob
or
smaug
Very Evil Smilie
who and why?
smaug, i like dragons more than spiders although i do like spiders... and other evil things... Very Evil Smilie Very Evil Smilie Very Evil Smilie Very Evil Smilie Very Evil Smilie Very Evil Smilie Very Evil Smilie Very Evil Smilie

Boromir
or
Faramir
Who and Why?
Faramir. Boromir sortta freaked me out in the end. And Faramir's every bit as brave as Boromir only with more wisdom.

Elrond
or
Elros?
who and why!
Elrond, he is an elf. Also he is the father of Arwen. Also i dont know much about Elros

Gimli
or
Gloin
Who and Why?
Gloin... I should have liked to join the hobbit's journey.....

Hurin
or
Huor

who and why?
Huor. I like to die a clean quick death in battle instead of living a dead life...

Bill the Pony
or
Shadowfax?


who and why?
bill!! doesn't have to run that fast... Wink Smilie

deagol
or
smeagol

who and why?
Tough choice, Ithil...

I'd have to say Deagol. He died, but that was nothing compared to Smeagol's ordeals after he killed his friend.

1. Radagast in Rosgobel
OR
2. Feanor in Aman

Who and why?
wow,... maybe feanor, I should say. hes just a very fascinating character with an impressing personality.

faramir (the suppressed son)
or
eomer (the orphan nephew)

who and why?
Faramir. He's got that bit of a quality that makes him much more than just a pretty warrior who tragically doesn't get loved by his father...

One of Vaire's maidens, sewing in her halls,
or
One of Aule's smiths, working in his smithies?

who and why?
first. because I'm not suitable for hard work, I'm not very strong. Very Sad Smilie and I guess the maidens were certainly able to wear the most beautiful dresses, and elven dresses are somewhat wonderful to me...

melkor
or
manwe
Manwe because 1) I'm a goody goody 2) I cannot imagine getting thrust into that *shudder* Void 3)and also I wouldn't like to get on the bad side of Feanor...

Cirdan the Shipwright
or
Earendil the Mariner?
who and why?
cirdan... don't ask me why, I just feel like it right now...

gandalf on top of orthanc
or
saruman in orthanc

who and why?
Saruman. It's good to feel as if you had others in your power (even if sometimes, things go just a leetle bit wrong)

Aragorn going to the paths of the dead
or
Theoden marching head-on to war
aragorn, I think... he knows they got to obey him, or does he not? Wary Smilie

arwen
or
eowyn


who and why?
Éowyn because she is somewhat "tougher" than Arwen (and i know that arwen is awesome also)

Aragorn
or
Faramir
Who and Why?
aragorn. I really don't like faramir, as one of the few ones that seem to do so. but don't ask me why...

gandalf
or
galadriel


who and why?
Gandalf coz of his exiting life and adventures
Theoden or Denethor ?
Who and why ?
I really really wish I had some of Denethor's farsight, but I'd rather be Theoden over him because being at least he was a better king than Denethor was a steward. I mean, he actually fought the war, right? Rather than just sitting there waiting for doom to come...

Galadriel
or
Celeborn?


Who and why?

galadriel. I know more about her life and I think it's really exciting and interesting... and she's one of the eldest elves in ME, she's seen the trees, hasn't she?

gothmog
or
the mouth of sauron


who and why?
Gothmog! BURN THEM!!! (i'm a Pyro....)

Elros or Elrond?
Elrond. I surely don't want to become the first king of the drowned kingdom Na-na-na-na-na Smilie
Turin
or
Hurin?
I think Turin !!! I have no idea why - maybe because he lived a bit longer (I think)

Hasufel

or

Arod


who and why??
Hasufel !! He carried ONLY Aragorn , Arod had to carry both Legolas and Gimli ( hope Im correct )
Witchking of Angmar
or
Gwahir ?
*whoahahahaha* witchking!!!!! Very Evil Smilie *arghh* he's one of my all-time favourites.... yeah, I do like this bad boy... *yes*

so, let's be more peaceful again...

rosie cotton
or
gaffer gamgee


who and why???
Gaffer Gamgee. For sense of humour
One of the Blue Istari
or
..another one?
the other one. Elf With a Big Grin Smilie

thorin oakenshield
or
bard


who and why?
Bard Bowman i presume? then him (Bard)

ellhoir or elladian (or something, which son of Elrond?)
Elladan. Sounds better
Mandos
or
Ulmo?
ulmo. like the lord of waters very much, he's kinda cool.

legolas
or
gimli


who and why?
LEGOLAS!!!! cuz 1. Elves are prettier than dwarves. and 2. Legolas is awesomer! lolololololol

Morgoth
or
Ungoliant
Who and Why?
morgoth... a more fascinating character than that ugly fat spider to me...

laurelin
or
telperion

who Wink Smilie and why?
Laurelin - coz she's female. Wink Smilie

Merry

or

Pippin


who and why?
Merry. Don't wanna hear "Fool of a Tuk!" from that maia in a hat Very Evil Smilie

Shagrat
or
Gorbag?

Who and why?
  [1] [2] [3] [4] >>