Login | Register
 
Message Board | Latest Posts | Your Recent Posts | Rules

Thread: Who and Why

Is this discussion interesting? Share it on Twitter!

Bottom of Page    Message Board > The Ivy Bush > Who and Why   << [1] [2] [3] [4] >>
Shagrat cuz the name sounds more eviller and stupider (which suits the character).

Varda
or
Yavanna?

who and why!
Varda. It must be great - being able to give the light.

Beren
or
Aragorn?

Who and why?
beren... I'd rather have lùthien as my girl than arwen. and they have this huge adventure together... beren's cool. Cool Smilie

so:
arwen
or
lùthien


who and why?
Luthien because she actually participated in the adventure. And also because she got to meet Huan the hound (I liked him). Finally, because she's the prettier one. Big Smile Smilie

Melkor in his might and glory beside Iluvatar at the world's beginning
or
Melkor in his strength and power at the gates of Angband
second, somehow. it should be interesting to see how you feel and act in such a situation of power. a look into the soul of such a person is always kinda fascinating...

thorin king under the mountain
or
balin lord of moria

who and why?
Thorin, I liked the mountains more. And also he got to be with Bilbo.

Saruman
or
Gandalf?
who and why?
Gandalf coz I love him so much !!!!
lord Elrond
or Celeborn ?

Who and Why ?
Elrond. I've always had a feeling that Celeborn is a kind of what in Russia call: an under-heel man. Maybe Professor would have argued with such an opinion...

Theoden
or
Eomer?
eomer. I like him more than theoden in some way.

fell beast
or
warg


who and why?
Fell beasts, don't like wargs or any demonic wolf things (although wolves themselves are quite beautiful)

Butterbur
or
Fatty Bolger?
who and why?
Butterbur...because he helps the hobbits when they are in Bree...although he is a little forgetful.

Gimli
or
Legolas
Who and Why?
Legolas because he fights gracefully(speaking from the movies) and also because he has the better voice (from the books, he always did the singing)

Treebeard
or
Quickbeam
treebeard!! he's so old, he's experienced so much, he's cool. Cool Smilie

tom bombadil
or
goldberry

who and why??
TOM TOM TOM!!! because he wears a bright blue jacket and his boots are yellow...i like blue and yellow...lol...but really because he helped save the hobbits!!!!!...what would we do with out old Tom

Gandalf
or
Radaghast
Who and Why?
Gandalf! I'd love the chance to say "Tell me, friend, when did Saruman the Wise abandon wisdom for madness?" right at old Saru's stinking face.

Elros
or
Aragorn?
Aragorn, because he knows so much and has had a lot of different experiences. Not all of them were good, of course… but you learn, anyway.

Bill the Pony
Or
Glorfindel’s Horse
bill, I should say. he had a hard life, but he met those nice hobbits and could go on adventures with them. *yea*

Yavanna
or
Aule

who and why?
Yavanna.I like what she did.

Carcharoth
or
Glaurung?
Carcaroth. I'd like the honour of eating Beren's hand Moderator Smilie

Thingol
or
Melian?
Thingol coz she is so nasty Orc Grinning Smilie
Haldir
or Telchar?

Who and Why ?
Haldir cause he's an elf (no offense)... and quite a brave one...

Luthien Tinuviel or Idril Celebrindal? why?
Luthien. For she was not only very powerful (being able to make Morgoth himself fall asleep), but also a reformer (marrying a mortal), and also she received a gift of Iluvatar and didn't have to wait in the Halls of Mandos, and, of course, she was the most beautiful creature of Middle-Earth! Who would refuse being that? Cat Smilie

Roheryn
or
Snowmane?
Roheryn of course because he gets to carry the King of Gondor!!

Gandalf the Grey
or
Gandalf the White?
Gandalf the Grey cuz he had an awsome hat...and he was more..approachable, frindly ect.

Elros
or
Elhoir
Elros cuz he got to meet the Elves of the first age.

A tree in Yavanna's garden
or
a tree in Lorien's garden?
Well, if being a tree is obligatory I'd choose a mallorn, who knows what did Yavanna grow in her gardens???

Aragorn
or
Legolas?


I want Elessar lossehelin to answer that!!! Bad King Smilie
and tell us why that question bothers him so much
Since Elessar lossehelin doesnt reply , my answer is Aragorn because of his devoted love to Arwen
Melkor
or
Gangalf the White
WHO AND WHY ?

Finally I got 1000 post !!
Gandalf the White, because I'd like to see the look on the orcs' faces when they are defeated, and I 'd like to sail to Valinor afterwards.

Frodo in Bag End
or
Frodo on the Undying Lands
Who and why?
Frodo in Bag Ends because I would like to see the inside of a Hobbits home and Im sure that Frodo also liked it very much!!
Pippin as a towerguard
or
Merry when his with Eowen , in the final battle
WHO AND WHY ?
I woud have chose Pip the towerguard a bit more safer than the outside

Men of dunhov or wraith?
who and why?!
Men of Dunhov, coz I look good in pantsSmile Smilie

Beren
or
Turin ?
Who and Why ?
Turin. If you accept the prophecy, I'd have loved to strike down Melkor.

Melkor
OR
Fingolfin

Who and Why?
Fingolfin.

I couldn't bear to be stuck in dreary old Angband all the time...

Treebeard in woods
or
Gwaihir in mountains?
Well, I'd like to visit Treebeard in the woods, but I'd like to soar with Gwaihir over the mountains even more; though not in them. Elf Winking Smilie

With who and why?

Sam hunting for Frodo in the Tower of Cirith Ungol

or

Bilbo rescuing the Dwarves from the Spiders in Mirkwood
Bilbo in Mirkwood! Cirith Ungol is almost as bad as Angband! And besides, the little episode of spider-tangling was quite entertaining.

Voronwe guiding Tuor
or
Beleg guiding Turin?


Who and Why?
Quote:
I want Elessar lossehelin to answer that!!!
and tell us why that question bothers him so much


Sorry I didn't answer that, and I havn't heard/seen any trace of Elen for a while now, but out of courtesy I'll answer Orc Smiling Smilie

I'd choose Aragorn, he accomplished alot more than Legolas, got the girl of his dreams and gets to tell a huge amount of people what to do, Legolas on the other hand made friends with a dwarf and shrieks alot (refering to Balrog). Although, I don't know what she meant by "why does it bother me so much?" oh well, If you shall ever return, I shall gladly give you an answer. Now onto Clover Orc Smiling Smilie

I'd choose Voronwe guiding Tuor, because Ulmo played a part, I like it when Valar are mentioned, plus the fact that he helped a messenger of one of the Valar is indeed a great responsibility

Sauron in a physical body
or
Sauron as a Spirit?


Who and Why???
Sauron as a Spirit! It is proven easier to kill a physical body than a spirit!

Smaug or Shelob ?
Who and why?
Smaug .. coz then id get to lie on a bed of gold !! Very Big Grin Smilie

Eorl the Young

or

Cirion the steward of gondor
Eorl the young definitly. i never liked the stewards because it is due to one of them that the crown was refused to arvedui and thus the northern lines.

Merry

or

pippin
Túrin

or

Húrin
Pippin, because Merry was kind of a stick in the mud. Elf With a Big Grin Smilie

Hurin, because I like hanging around mountains. Elf Sticking Tounge Out Smilie

Drinking in the Shire with Tom Bombadil

or

Gardening with Sam at Bag End

Who and Why?


Moderator Smilie Please don't forget to review your new posts and add the [ /b] to turn off the bold highlighting. - Thanks

Also this is the Who and Why thread, not the Dual Word thread. Orc Grinning Smilie
Drinking & singing with Tom; admitting I do not have green fingers Sam Gamgee has.

Gimli with Frodo
or
Thorin Oakienshield with Bilbo


Who and why
Gimli with Frodo because Thorin was a stuffed shirt.

With Ioreth in the Houses of Healing

or

With Bergil on the streets of Gondor


Question Smilie
loreth so i can sew her mouth shut!

Feanor

or

Fingolfin
Fingolfin because he was one of the most noble and valiant of the Elves. Fëanor was too full of himself to suit me.

Finrod

or

Turgon

Turgon, because I see Gondolin as a neater place to live than Nargothrond.

Bill Ferny

or

Ted Sandyman

Who and why?
UGH what a nasty choice... Alright I guess Sandyman because he wasn't downright malicious and evil like Ferny, rather Ted was stupid and easily misled. Elf Winking Smilie

Glaurung or Smaug?

Who and why?
Glaurung, because were I able to find a rock and a hard spot, I might weasel my way between them and escape from him, for he's too enormous to follow. Smaug would just fly over it and that scorch spot you'd see on the other side would be Grondy. Big Laugh Smilie

Theoden or Denethor?

Who and why?
Theoden because he was full of hope and glory in his final days, whereas Denethor was full of despair and madness.

On a related note....Eomer or Faramir?
Eomer... cause then I would get to take part in the battle of the Pelennor Field and get to witness the destruction and downfall of Mordor and Sauron.

Turgon or Fingolfin?
  << [1] [2] [3] [4] >>