Thanks!

Yes, Dragons are VERY cool. Have you ever read The Last Dragonlord? If you like dragons you HAVE to read it. It's So good!

Elves totally rule! Legoals is an elf!

Nope, wouldn't want to be a dragon. Too many hotshots out there trying to kill dragons!

I would want to be an elf or a hobbit. I love them both.

I'd come back as an elven warrior like Lord Elrond

I want to be an ranger so I can sleep under the stars.

That's cos the d*mn roadrunner keeps getting away.

I think other than being a hobbit, a wizard is kinda cool with all the power and stuff. Of course it 'd be better if I could be a young witch with the same amount of power as a wizard - I don't think there are any witches in the book or maybe I'm mistaken.

Yet she had no spells, but if she set out on you with her old umbrella, you might be in for a dizzy spell. Her fiercest weapon was a sharp tongue. I doubt if she had any swear words in her repertoire, knowing no sailors from which to learn them: she was of upper crust Hobbiton after all.

Hey Naira!

What about the Witch King?

I know, Grondy, therefore I put the smiley. Oh well, guess I was in a weird mood yesterday.

Hmmm. I'd have to think about that!

I would have to go with..um..hard to say..NOT! An Elf of course! I agree with Ally on this one But I`m not sure where I want to settle..either in Rivendell or Lothlorien..I LOVE trees and forests, but I also love Rivendells open and warm enviroment...maybe I can travel between? Yup, definetly an Elf

/me blushes

Awww... thanks. And what's shampoo

Ok, well, I look like a Beorning and I kinda have the attitude of one. And I really like Honey, honeycakes and cream... But I like meat, too, and T think they don't eat meat.

I respect the hardiness of the Dunedain and their wisdom and ability to affect the plan of Illuvatar where no one else can... But they are not immortal and seem to have lots of problems govering themselves.

Dwarves are cool but just too stodgy and i like living in the sunlight.

I have been accused of being a really overgrown Hobbit due to my fondess of an uncomplicated lifestyle and desire to get as many meals as I can a day. Second Breakfast anyone? And their hobbit holes look really comfortable... So that is a definite possibility.

I love music, song, singing, listening to stories and storytelling, good food, the Moon and the Stars and being in Nature. I would really love to have the gracefulness of an Elf. Preferably a Vanyar or Noldorin Elf, but any will really do. And immortality is a really nice bonus. Yes, I would like to be an Elf. Not an overbearing, distant, imperious, too full of himself Elf, but rather a friendly giving elf with a big house for guests to hang in and food and music to share. Actually, just like Elrond.

Hey no one has thought about being an eagle?
I'm still a Nandor though.



It depends on if the doom af Mandos hangs over them or not!

It implies in the silmarillion that they are two different Glorfindel's but it would be cool if there the same. The mother of Feanor can also come back at anytime, she just choose's not to, she didn't do anything that much out of the ordinary. I mean Feanor wasn't that super.

I read a long and detailed essay on this subject on another site some months ago. A lot of research had been done into the subject by the postAuthorID of the essay, but even his answer was unconclusive. Evidence did seem to suggest, however, that Tolkien had written the Fall of Gondolin very early in his career, and had included Glorfindel in this story. He had also included this first Glorfindel and a couple of other elven lords in another unpublished story, in which they had failed in some quest or something (I think it might have been something to do with guarding Aredhel), after which Glorfindel was seeking some sort of penance.

It then suggested through his evidence that Tolkien had introduced another Glorfindel in Rivendell, and at first Tolkien had intended the two Glorfindels being the same elf. Apparently, however, as his writing increased and his stories evolved, he ran into difficulties explaining how the two elves could be one and the same. The main arguement had been, if Glorfindel had died in Middle Earth during the First Age, how had he managed to return back to Middle Earth for the Third Age, when Aman was effectively closed to passage for the Noldor.

Anyway, having come across difficulties of his own making, Tolkien had then gone to pains to make the two Glorfindels different elves. Not painful enough maybe, in my opinion, but like the fate of Elrond's sons, and the mystery of what is Tom Bombadil, he has left us with another mystery to muse over.

What do you mean "what race would i be"?
I am an elf!

If I culd be any other race i'd be an elf because then i'd have the chance to talk the cooliest language ever and i'd also be as light as the wind...

elfs ar just the cooliest

i think Einar should be a numenorian as she/he (delete as appropriate, i dont mean to cause offence) is obviously afraid of death!

Nothing weird about that "little" girl, we tree-huggers come in all sizes.

if I was to be any race it would have to be the hobbits. They are so laid back and just like to chill out in the sun. Soak up some rays have some mead and pipeweed, what more can u ask for and maybe going on a few adventures if it took their fancy

Welcome to Planet Tolkien, Darous. Although we all dream of heroic adventures, at the end of the day most of us prefer dreaming about them rather than actually taking part in them. I think there's a bit of Hobbit in everyone who enjoys a putting their feet up in front of the fire after a good meal, and watching a bit of TV etc.
Maybe not Grondy, but I bet they'd have taken advantage of them if they had.