Login | Register
 
Message Board | Latest Posts | Your Recent Posts | Rules

Thread: Post Of Whenever - August

Is this discussion interesting? Share it on Twitter!

Bottom of Page    Message Board > Post of the Week > Post Of Whenever - August   
Laurelindhe ilmarin posted Thursday 26th August 2004 (06:17pm) in Characters > Was Tom Bombadil Important :

Quote:
I agree with your theory on Goldberry, Astaldo-at least her cultural background-but also she could have been a Druid or a Celtic spirit or a nymph or something along those lines(maybe an Atlantean because she springs from water?).

As for Tom Bombadil, these are my feelings:

If we look at the stories alone as solitary tales, unrelated in any way, then a lot of the places or characters do not seem to fit in with each particular story; i.e. Beorn, Bombadil, the Ents, or even Old Man Willow. However, we know that these tales were related in that they convey a larger picture: the whole of Middle Earth, its history, its races, its gods, its enemies, etc. The fact that they are not all cohesive or complete is very logical-no history is ever all-encompassing. Certain facts and events are non-intentionally omitted because to include EVERYTHING would be impossible, because by the time the recorder finished recounting a certain era, said era would have passed. Does that make any sense?

If we look at Bombadil as a detail, rather than an anomolie, then he becomes essential to the recounting of the history of Middle Earth, regardless of his relevance to Lord of the Rings. He is as important as any of the other details-colors, scents, armor, architecture, poems/lays/songs, the different tribes of men, locations, etc. and so forth. Without any of these details, you would be left with a hollow story, and one not half as good as it is. It is the details of a story or history that make it both interesting and accurate. A detail examined by itself has no meaning, but when looked at in a broader scope in relation to the Big Picture, it becomes not only important, but inherent to the story's power to hold our interest.

What I am trying to say (in a very rambling manner) is that the recounting of the story of the War of the Ring, and all that precedes it or follows it, and Middle Earth itself, would not be complete without Tom as he lends richness of detail to FOTR. Also, as I believe was mentioned before, he does serve to give both the hobbits and the reader a rest-all of the events prior to and after they meet Tom are quite anxiety-ridden; Tolkien knew this and probably wanted to ease our reading a bit.

As for Tom's origin, I don't have a clue, but the most logical theory that I've heard so far is (Grondy's?) the idea that TB might be a corporeal incarnation of Eru. That, to me, makes the most sense.Smile Smilie


A very good post on good old Tom. Congratulations Laurelindhe. 100 pieces of Mithril will be coming your way when we are able to do so. Smile Smilie
My gosh! Me? Is there some trickiness going on? Wow! Thank you all! ***bows with humility***

Well, I better watch myself now that I know someone is actually listening...

Pary Smilie Exclamation Smilie Jumping Flame Smilie Juggling Smilie Elk Grinning Smilie Elf With a Big Grin Smilie
No trickses, my precioussssss....... just a very good post.

Wiggle Smilie Wiggle Smilie Wiggle Smilie Wiggle Smilie
Wiggle Smilie Wiggle Smilie Wiggle Smilie Wiggle Smilie
Wiggle Smilie Wiggle Smilie Wiggle Smilie Wiggle Smilie

Deserves some line dancing!
Very nice post, and a well-deserved award! Thumbs Up Smilie

Wiggle Smilie Wiggle Smilie Wiggle Smilie
Whee!! Congratulations to you Laurelindhe!!! I'll join the linedancing:

Pary Smilie Wiggle Smilie Wiggle Smilie Wiggle Smilie Pary Smilie
Pary Smilie Wiggle Smilie Wiggle Smilie Wiggle Smilie Pary Smilie
Pary Smilie Wiggle Smilie Wiggle Smilie Wiggle Smilie Pary Smilie
Pary Smilie Wiggle Smilie Wiggle Smilie Wiggle Smilie Pary Smilie

(Grondy merly reduced the group of dancers to a more manageble number.) Happy Elf Smilie
(Gildor says sorry.) Happy Elf Smilie
Yes! I love the line dancing! Can I add an animal line dance for all of you who gave me your line dances?

Cat Smilie Dog Smilie Duck Smilie Puppy Smilie Tigger Smilie Wolf Smilie Oink Smilie

Cat Smiling Smilie Chicken Smilie Cow Sleeping Smilie Elk Grinning Smilie

I must say that these animals do not look too active, and they are certainly not in a line, so I have decided that they are all contemplating doing a line dance! However, I heard it on strict authority from the cow that they are all saluting you guys all the same. Thank you for the congrats!

You guys rock!
Nice post Laurelindhe ilmarin, I enjoyed reading it! Congratulations on being selected for PotW!
Happy Elf Smilie
Congratulations, Laurelindhe ilmarin. Nice post.
Way to go! Laurelindhe ilmarin: your post deserved the award. Jumping Flame Smilie
Yes, the only post made outside a tavern indeed deserves credit. Excelsior!