Login | Register
 
Message Board | Latest Posts | Your Recent Posts | Rules

Thread: The Hobbit 2.

Is this discussion interesting? Share it on Twitter!

Bottom of Page    Message Board > The Hobbit (Movie) > The Hobbit 2.   
[quote="chris63":3evjlvau]2 Hobbit movies a bridging movie a book of unfinished tales the Silmarillion even Farmer Giles of Ham can all be made into movies. think that would be great.[/quote:3evjlvau]

I'm not sure how most of UT, [i:3evjlvau]The Silmarillion[/i:3evjlvau], or anything of Farmer Giles relates to [i:3evjlvau]The Hobbit[/i:3evjlvau]. If you meant as separate projects I could see your point, though I have no desire to see filmmakers/scriptwriters go and 'flesh out' Tolkien's unfinished stories (as would be necessary). As for Farmer Giles I must admit I've never read it, but since it's not Middle-earth-oriented I have a feeling a lot of people would be disappointed (regardless of how good the movie is itself). I'd probably go see it though.
I am almost certain I should have posted this in a prexisting thread. But I havent been particularly active recently so. I dont really know whats going on and where. Anyway.

Do you think the hobbit films will be titled as, part 1 and part 2 or will someone get creative and try to come up with a title for each part.

My suggestions would be, part one as The hobbit, There. and part two as The hobbit, and back again. Ofc I am joking.

Incidentaly who thinks the second film should open with Smaugs decent onto Erebor? I would be interested to see his actual purge of the mountain. And it fits with the vision of expanding the main story.
movie one: The Hobbit
movie two: There and Back Again

it would be simple, yet fair. just an idea
seems to me they may work "Battle of the 5 Armies"
into it somewhere....to make it sound more badass.
[quote="Elladan":spb2jdq2]Do you think the hobbit films will be titled as, part 1 and part 2 or will someone get creative and try to come up with a title for each part.[/quote:spb2jdq2]

I think the first one will be called [i:spb2jdq2]The Hobbit[/i:spb2jdq2] and the second will have its own name, or perhaps it's own subtitle (i.e., [i:spb2jdq2]The Hobbit: ____[/i:spb2jdq2]). I really don't know, but I doubt it'll just be part 1 and part 1.

[quote:spb2jdq2]Incidentaly who thinks the second film should open with Smaugs decent onto Erebor? I would be interested to see his actual purge of the mountain. And it fits with the vision of expanding the main story.[/quote:spb2jdq2]

You mean a flashback to when he first came there? That could be quite interesting ... somewhat like the flashback to the finding of the Ring in [i:spb2jdq2]The Return of the King[/i:spb2jdq2]. It could definitely work, though I'm not entirely fond with the whole notion of expansion to begin with.
[quote="Bargolwash":3e4p90os]movie one: The Hobbit
movie two: There and Back Again[/quote:3e4p90os]

I don't think [i:3e4p90os]There and Back Again[/i:3e4p90os] would work for the second movie because the "There" part has already been done and it's just being at the destination and then returning. I suppose they could call the first movie [i:3e4p90os]There[/i:3e4p90os] and the second one [i:3e4p90os]Back Again[/i:3e4p90os] for an overall title of [i:3e4p90os]There and Back Again[/i:3e4p90os] though. :lol:
part 1. There

part 2. and back. :lol: <img src='/images/smileys/bigsmile.gif' border='0' alt='Big Smile Smilie' /> :roll:
Hey, guys!
I'm looking for the official " Hobbit, the " website. Does anybody can help me?
Hi Katya! It's a bit premature for there to be an official site of any substance yet since the first film's projected release date is still over two years away. The closest thing that I am aware of is [url=http://www.thehobbitblog.com/:931y70ds]The Official Movie Blog[/url:931y70ds] though that hasn't been updated in about 18 months. Right now fansites are the best place to get news and rumouurs about [i:931y70ds]The Hobbit[/i:931y70ds]. In addition to this site theonering.net is pretty good too.

I hope you'll stick around here and discuss [i:931y70ds]The Hobbit[/i:931y70ds], LOTR, Middle-earth, Tolkien, and more. It can be pretty fun. :mrgreen:
I was thinking maybe they'll call the first one The Hobbit, and the second one a chapter title. The Gathering of the Clouds would seem like a decent title from a chapter name.
[quote="demonslyr":1mt55qom]I guess it would be better if The Hobbit was made into two movies, but it just doesn't feel right for some reason...[/quote:1mt55qom]

I agree. It's one book and one story, I see no reason why it shouldn't be one movie. Other than that they are adding to the story, but if we're on the subject of what [i:1mt55qom]should[/i:1mt55qom] be then I don't think they should do that either! :P

[quote:1mt55qom]Haha. Don't mind me. :P[/quote:1mt55qom]

Nah, I like talking with people. :mrgreen: Welcome to the forum!
I guess it would be better if The Hobbit was made into two movies, but it just doesn't feel right for some reason...

Haha. Don't mind me. :P
More movies the better if you ask me. I only like fantasy/si fi movies and
90% of these are crap, so 2 Hobbit movies a bridging movie a book of unfinished tales the Silmarillion even Farmer Giles of Ham can all be made into movies. think that would be great. <img src='/images/smileys/bigsmile.gif' border='0' alt='Big Smile Smilie' /> <img src='/images/smileys/bigsmile.gif' border='0' alt='Big Smile Smilie' /> <img src='/images/smileys/bigsmile.gif' border='0' alt='Big Smile Smilie' />
Farmer Giles of Ham is a hoot. Another middle aged middle class well to do person going off to fight an interesting dragon. I read it recently in Tales from the Perlious Realm; for the second time, actually, for I also read it years ago in a different edition. Well worth a look - but it's not TH nor LOTR. I can't ever imagine anyone ever being bold enough to film it.

Odo