Oh, ooh, I think I've got it... is it:

Adunakhor, Lord of the West

(don't know where all the accents and thingies go on his name)

I'd better let someone else take it from here as I don't have internet access over weekends.

Would you do the honours Caudi?

Caudi, Caudi...I like that. Most people just abbreviate it to Caud, but I like Caudi. I will guess an "i" for the one Tinúviel added. Thanks Tinúviel for the new nick name.

One i please

It's a pleasure Caudi, glad you like it, sounds more..? endearing with an i.

I'd like an S please.

I guess I will guess an L, because Grondy decided to change me to Claudi though I don't think I like the addition of the L. I think Claudi resembles to closely to Claudia, which is quite female, while I am not.

Anyways an L please.

can i have a T, Grondy???

No problem, you gave me the next correct letter so I don't mind. But now I am stuck, please don't tell me that there aren't any H's

Yes, we have one H, two Is, and two Ls for Caudi; three As and four Ns for Mello; two Ss for Tinú; and two Es and two Ts for Loss.

So now it reads:

_ I _ I L _ H A _ / _ A S / S T _ _ N _ / A N _ / _ N _ E N T L E

Sorry, still no wrong guesses.

i should think that an R should go in there somewhere, so an R kind sir

Yes, we have two Ds, one H, two Is, and two Ls for Caudi; three As and four Ns for Mello; three Gs and two Ss for Tinú; and two Es, one R, and two Ts for Loss.

So now it reads:

G I _ I L _ H A D / _ A S / S T R _ N G / A N D / _ N G E N T L E
Sorry, still no wrong guesses.

i got it!!!! its;

Gimilkhad was strong and ungentle

i knew i recognised the first word

okay here we go:

_ _ _ / _ _ _ _ _ N _ / _ _ / _ _ _ / _ _ _ _ / _ _ _ _ _ N _

and 2 N's for Grondy

and no wrong guesses

Okay, I'll try for the F next, if you please?

May I have a T or two then Loss ?

Of course you did I meant an H or two ..sorry

O looks like it could fit.

T H E / _ _ _ _ _ N _ / O F / T H E / _ _ E _ / _ O _ _ _ N _

2 N's and 1 F for Grondy, 2 T's and 2 H's for Mellon, 2 O's for Caudimordax and 3 E's for Tubby

no M's for Grondy

I guess I'll guess an L next, for Professor Tolkien used lots of those in his writings. So please, may I have an L or two?

T H E / _ _ _ _ _ N _ / O F / T H E / _ R E _ / _ O _ _ _ N _

2 N's and 1 F for Grondy, 2 T's 1 R and 2 H's for Mellon, 2 O's for Caudimordax and 3 E's for Tubby

no M's or L's for Grondy (looks like JRRT didnt use L in this part )
no U's for Tinúviel

keep going guys you are nearly there!!!

Ok, I'll try a D?

T H E / _ _ S S _ N _ / O F / T H E / _ R E _ / _ O _ _ _ N _

2 N's, 2 S's and 1 F for Grondy, 2 T's 1 R and 2 H's for Mellon, 2 O's for Caudimordax and 3 E's for Tubby

no M's or L's for Grondy
no U's or D's for Tinúviel
no K's for Mellon

Can I have a A Loss?

OOOHHH sorry Grondy, yes there is an M my mistake (sorry about that)

T H E / _ A S S _ N _ / O F / T H E / G R E _ / C O M _ A N _

2 N's, 2 S's, 1 M 1 G and 1 F for Grondy, 2 T's 1 R, 1 C and 2 H's for Mellon, 2 O's for Caudimordax and 3 E's for Tubby and 2 A's for Weneryn (welcome to PT)

no L's for Grondy
no U's or D's for Tinúviel
no K's for Mellon

May I have some Ys please, and while your at it my other G.

I believe an i will do it.

It is the name of a chapter in RotK. Actually quick question when reading that chapter it doesn't clarify whether the "Grey Company" was Aragorn and his company, or the company of the undead. At some points it seems like it is the one; at others, it seems like it is the other. Which is it?...Or was Tolkien purposefully being vague to mean which ever one you like. Thoughts to ponder.

Because I have new thinking and reading material apparently, I will decline the creation of the next puzzle. First come, first serve.