Actually, I thought the problem was that there was MORE character development than there was in the books

(following logically on many of the "purist" arguments, particularly in regard to Aragorn and Faramir).
All kidding aside, I totally disagree that the films were unbalanced in favour of excessive CGI. The CGI and special effects were brilliant and effective but clearly in service to the story and characters rather than the reverse. If there are any more extended sequences in future editions of the films, I wouldn't be averse to more effects sequences, as well as character interaction.
I do agree with you in general though Petty. CGI and Special Effects without a good story or characters can be tedious at times, but it rather depends on how well done the action sequences are. I can totally enjoy a crap film plot if the action is well filmed.
[b:3d947tzu]GB[/b:3d947tzu]