Thread: For the one who loves the books and don't really like the movie
i don't know why i say that we'll never do a movie, i must stop dreaming...
WE HAVE TO DO A MOVIE EXACLY THE BOOK
That movie would take between 20 and 30 hours. So we usually don't call it a movie but a mini-series.
I, as everyone knows, despise the fact that PJ did those changes...I of course could understand if he cut some parts out...but to change the plot and characters?
He probably did that because he wanted to make a movie that ppl who never heard of JRRT before could be able to enjoy. So he cut stuff out.
But i still don't see why he changed the plot and characters. Maybe he had to do this because he cut and changed some stuff so he had to change the characters with the rest too.
Anyway, we get a movie that way that even Tolkienites can't follow here and there. Arwen, anyone?
me to Irma,love movies before i read the books.Three years later with eight tolkien books for reading,i now am a heavy book purist