Quote:
Arwen and Aragorn are realated...kind of gross
Arwen and Aragorn are realated...kind of gross
They are related hundreds of years back so I don't think it really counts.
Thread: Some thoughts...
Planet Tolkien is archived and no longer updated, but the forums remain browseable. We have established a Telegram group for old and new visitors to stay connected and discuss all things Tolkien.
They are related hundreds of years back so I don't think it really counts.
Jajajaja, yes but they are still realted, mhh, and also Arwen is hundreds of years older than Aragorn, 
just kiding.pr the thought that bilbo is a single old hobbit who is living all allone and then suddenly takes another young hobbit in his keeping whom misteriously stays single too :P and this hobbit gets very close with his gardner who comes to live with him :P and as a cover-up he marries rosie :P
*shudder* oh man i always wondered why such a desireable Hobbit like Frodo never went for Hobbit women ....oh great now everytime i read the Hobbit ill be thinking about 13 dwarves and Bilbo alone in dark Mirkwood and Bilbo with a magic ring that makes him Invisible
ROFLMAO
OMG the hobbit isn't a childrens book afterall.
it's p*rn*groph* it's sick 13 dwarves and a hobbit :P bleuh.. nice hairy dwarves
OMG the hobbit isn't a childrens book afterall.
it's p*rn*groph* it's sick 13 dwarves and a hobbit :P bleuh.. nice hairy dwarves
Can we pleeeeeeease get off that subject?*bangs head on keyboard*lsdkjfghj I am tired of talking the gay hobbit thing!
Quote:
I am tired of talking the gay hobbit thing!
So am I! Please God, MAKE IT STOP!! I am tired of talking the gay hobbit thing!
Me too.
You know what they say about Homophobic people and people obssed with homosexuallity!
[Edited on 22/1/2003 by Ross]
You know what they say about Homophobic people and people obssed with homosexuallity!
[Edited on 22/1/2003 by Ross]
Yes I do know. Watch you step now Ross, people might get upset. (Actually I wanted to say that myself, but couldn't find the words)
haha geez I'm not homophobic, one of my best friends is gay, its just the thought of the hairy dwarves that i.....nah lol ok off the subject of gayness in the hobbit thanks for you comments though
Arwen and Aragorn are related?? They were very very (lightyears almost) distant family.
How about Galadriel and Celeborn ? They were cousins !
Galadriel is the grand-daughter of Olw’, whilst Celeborn is the grand-son of Elmo, Olw’'s brother.
I thought this is prohibited in a lot of countries today...
How about Galadriel and Celeborn ? They were cousins !
Galadriel is the grand-daughter of Olw’, whilst Celeborn is the grand-son of Elmo, Olw’'s brother.
I thought this is prohibited in a lot of countries today...
Quote:
How about Galadriel and Celeborn ? They were cousins !
Galadriel is the grand-daughter of Olw’, whilst Celeborn is the grand-son of Elmo, Olw’'s brother.
Had they both been grandchildren of Olwe, they would have been first cousins, but as they did not share the same grandparent they were only second cousins. I think that is permissable in most countries (it is in the UK anyway)How about Galadriel and Celeborn ? They were cousins !
Galadriel is the grand-daughter of Olw’, whilst Celeborn is the grand-son of Elmo, Olw’'s brother.
Quote:
I think that is permissable in most countries (it is in the UK anyway)
I think that is permissable in most countries (it is in the UK anyway)
You can marry your cousin over here, I know they do in Heywood!
Quote:
You can marry your cousin over here, I know they do in Heywood!
I know what you mean Ross. I think in my neck of the woods it's permissible to marry your sister.You can marry your cousin over here, I know they do in Heywood!
I think I remember hearing somewhere that third cousins are essentially genetically unrelated.
The laws here probably vary from state to state... I'm fairly sure that second cousins are legally allowed to marry in New Jersey though I wouldn't swear to it.
But I bet in Tennesee there are a few kids referring to their parents as Uncle Dad and Aunt Mom
The laws here probably vary from state to state... I'm fairly sure that second cousins are legally allowed to marry in New Jersey though I wouldn't swear to it.
But I bet in Tennesee there are a few kids referring to their parents as Uncle Dad and Aunt Mom
Come on guys. In most places first cousins are not allowed to legally marry as it tends to make the regressive genes dominant.
Next thing you'll be telling me is that, 'you are your own grandpa', just like in that song of my youth.
Next thing you'll be telling me is that, 'you are your own grandpa', just like in that song of my youth.
Quote:
But I bet in Tennesee there are a few kids referring to their parents as Uncle Dad and Aunt Mom
But I bet in Tennesee there are a few kids referring to their parents as Uncle Dad and Aunt Mom
*Ahem* that is my state my friend!
Quote:
*Ahem* that is my state my friend!
*Ahem* that is my state my friend!
We rest our case!
No offence really meant Stony.
Now behave yourselves people. 
It is not uncommon for royalty and nobility to marry second cousins. No one else but their own family is good enough, apparently. If you look at the British royal family, going back a few generations, it is surprising how many couples were already distantly related. I am not trying to deride the royals, it was just common practice a while back.
Elrond and Celebrian were also distantly related (via Galadriel's family), as were Elwing and Earendil.
However, Feanor's 'attraction' to Galadriel seems to have been considered innapropriate, and Maeglin's desire for Idril (first cousins) was considered incestuous. Even elves appear to have had resrictions on whom they could marry.
It is not uncommon for royalty and nobility to marry second cousins. No one else but their own family is good enough, apparently. If you look at the British royal family, going back a few generations, it is surprising how many couples were already distantly related. I am not trying to deride the royals, it was just common practice a while back.
Elrond and Celebrian were also distantly related (via Galadriel's family), as were Elwing and Earendil.
However, Feanor's 'attraction' to Galadriel seems to have been considered innapropriate, and Maeglin's desire for Idril (first cousins) was considered incestuous. Even elves appear to have had resrictions on whom they could marry.
Stonehelm, my whole family is from Tennesee! Ask Rednell, she's seen my family tree
I was by no means suggesting that all people from Tennesee are inbred any more than Val or Ross were about their respective hometowns.
I was by no means suggesting that all people from Tennesee are inbred any more than Val or Ross were about their respective hometowns.
Quote:
Come on guys. In most places first cousins are not allowed to legally marry as it tends to make the regressive genes dominant.
Next thing you'll be telling me is that, 'you are your own grandpa', just like in that song of my youth.
Come on guys. In most places first cousins are not allowed to legally marry as it tends to make the regressive genes dominant.
Next thing you'll be telling me is that, 'you are your own grandpa', just like in that song of my youth.
Really now, Grondmaster? It's allowed to marry your cousin in Sweden.. Uh.. No, I just don't want to think about it. *Aire shrugs*
I knew you were kidding around Prog
Quote:
It is not uncommon for royalty and nobility to marry second cousins. No one else but their own family is good enough, apparently. If you look at the British royal family, going back a few generations, it is surprising how many couples were already distantly related. I am not trying to deride the royals, it was just common practice a while back.
It is not uncommon for royalty and nobility to marry second cousins. No one else but their own family is good enough, apparently. If you look at the British royal family, going back a few generations, it is surprising how many couples were already distantly related. I am not trying to deride the royals, it was just common practice a while back.
Thats why our royalty have so much disease and insanity. There are also mainly responsible for Haemophilia being spread across the Royal families of Europe. The royal family don't you just love, they destroy themselves without you having ot lift a finger. Phil insults everyone, charles talks cr*p and to tree's and the rest of them spend there tme evading tax, gambling and getting drunk!
[Edited on 28/1/2003 by Rednell]
oh man i didn't mean for this to become an insest forum lol. But i have another random thought that i remembered, Elrond isn't really half elven, since Earendil was half elven and Elwing was an Elf wouldn't that make Elrond 3/4 elven?
By that reconing that would make me a quater Welsh, But I was born in England brought up in England therefore I am English (although I prefer British much more communal).
Quote:
By that reconing that would make me a quater Welsh, But I was born in England brought up in England therefore I am English (although I prefer British much more communal).
And Ross's comment (posted above on 27/1/2003 at 12:36) about the royal family, if made by anyone but a Brit, would be fighting words.By that reconing that would make me a quater Welsh, But I was born in England brought up in England therefore I am English (although I prefer British much more communal).
Please Ross (and all you others out there) refrain from talking non-Tolkien related politics on this forum
Thank you
Sorry grondy, but 69% of britain fells the same!
Quote:
Elrond isn't really half elven, since Earendil was half elven and Elwing was an Elf wouldn't that make Elrond 3/4 elven?
Elrond isn't really half elven, since Earendil was half elven and Elwing was an Elf wouldn't that make Elrond 3/4 elven?
Elrond is 5/8 elven. There is a more detailed discussion under characters, Earendill.
If you want Elrond's true blood breakdown read-on, if not ignore this post...
His mother, Elwing's line
Elwe (Elf) + Melian (Maiar) = Luthian (Half-elf/half-maiar)
Luthian + Beren (human) = Dior (Quarter-elf/quarter-maiar/half-human)
Dior + Nimroth (elf) = Elwing (Eighth-maiar/five-eighths elf/quarter-human)
Father, Earendil's line
Tuor (human) + Idril (elf) = Earendil (half-human/half-elf)
So Elrond is a mix of Elwing and Earendil which gives us the following....
Earendil (half-human/half-elf) + Elwing (Eighth-maiar/five-eighths elf/quarter-human) = Elrond
One sixteenth Maiar
nine sixteenths Elf
six sixteenths Human
His mother, Elwing's line
Elwe (Elf) + Melian (Maiar) = Luthian (Half-elf/half-maiar)
Luthian + Beren (human) = Dior (Quarter-elf/quarter-maiar/half-human)
Dior + Nimroth (elf) = Elwing (Eighth-maiar/five-eighths elf/quarter-human)
Father, Earendil's line
Tuor (human) + Idril (elf) = Earendil (half-human/half-elf)
So Elrond is a mix of Elwing and Earendil which gives us the following....
Earendil (half-human/half-elf) + Elwing (Eighth-maiar/five-eighths elf/quarter-human) = Elrond
One sixteenth Maiar
nine sixteenths Elf
six sixteenths Human
Whole elf, he choose to be an elf!
Well, first/second grade cousins rn't allowed to marry where i live... anyway. I've checked.
I don't know about this just can't think of anything at all...
