Thread: Character Elimination Game
Planet Tolkien is archived and no longer updated, but the forums remain browseable. We have established a Telegram group for old and new visitors to stay connected and discuss all things Tolkien.<< [1] [2] [3] >>
Again, five to Merry and five to Pippin.
8 PCPs... I will do the first Updated Scoreboard.
Round 2 - 8 PCPs - 1st Update
Frodo - 10
Morgoth - 30
Sam - 20
Witch King - 20
Boromir - 40
Merry - 30
Pippin - 30
Gandalf - 20
The Mouth of Sauron - 20
Aragorn - 20
’omer - 20
Gimli - 20
Legolas - 20
Faramir - 20
Thorin - 20
Round 2 - 8 PCPs - 1st Update
Frodo - 10
Morgoth - 30
Sam - 20
Witch King - 20
Boromir - 40
Merry - 30
Pippin - 30
Gandalf - 20
The Mouth of Sauron - 20
Aragorn - 20
’omer - 20
Gimli - 20
Legolas - 20
Faramir - 20
Thorin - 20
You left out Eowyn!
She would have been in round one, but the amount of people in there was too long, so she was one of them that was cut.
Eowyn will be included in round 1 of the next game. (Humans round, followed by Elves then Evil. the best 5 from each group go through into round 2 of that game.)
Eowyn will be included in round 1 of the next game. (Humans round, followed by Elves then Evil. the best 5 from each group go through into round 2 of that game.)
10 to Frodo, please, Cheesy 
6 to Frodo and 4 to Sam will be my expenditure today.
10 to the Witch-King
10 to the Witch King. The Witch king is through to the final 10.
Five to Merry and five to Pippin.
Another 10 to Frodo will be today's expenditure for me.
Round 2 - 15 PCPs - 2nd Update
Frodo - 26
Morgoth - 30
Sam - 24
Witch King - 40
Boromir - 40
Merry - 35
Pippin - 35
Gandalf - 20
The Mouth of Sauron - 20
Aragorn - 20
’omer - 20
Gimli - 20
Legolas - 20
Faramir - 20
Thorin - 20
Frodo - 26
Morgoth - 30
Sam - 24
Witch King - 40
Boromir - 40
Merry - 35
Pippin - 35
Gandalf - 20
The Mouth of Sauron - 20
Aragorn - 20
’omer - 20
Gimli - 20
Legolas - 20
Faramir - 20
Thorin - 20
1 from Faramir
2 from Gandalf
1 from Aragorn
3 to ’omer
2 to Morgoth
1 to Thorin
2 from Gandalf
1 from Aragorn
3 to ’omer
2 to Morgoth
1 to Thorin
10 from Merry.
Four to Gandalf, and six to Merry.
Another 10 to Frodo, please!
Five to Pippin, four to Merry and one to Aragorn.
1 to Morgoth.
9 from Merry.
9 from Merry.
Round 2 - Closed
Final Results
Frodo - 36
Morgoth - 33
Sam - 24
Witch King - 40
Boromir - 40
Merry - 24
Pippin - 40
Gandalf - 22
The Mouth of Sauron - 20
Aragorn - 20
’omer - 23
Gimli - 20
Legolas - 20
Faramir - 19
Thorin - 21
Round 2 - Leader Board
Boromir - 40
Pippin - 40
Witch King - 40
Frodo - 36
Morgoth - 33
Merry - 24
Sam - 24
’omer - 23
Gandalf - 22
Thorin - 21
Aragorn - 20
Gimli - 20
Legolas - 20
The Mouth of Sauron - 20
Faramir - 19
Round 3
Boromir - 20
Pippin - 20
Witch King - 20
Frodo - 20
Morgoth - 20
Merry - 20
Sam - 20
’omer - 20
Gandalf - 20
Thorin - 20
Final Results
Frodo - 36
Morgoth - 33
Sam - 24
Witch King - 40
Boromir - 40
Merry - 24
Pippin - 40
Gandalf - 22
The Mouth of Sauron - 20
Aragorn - 20
’omer - 23
Gimli - 20
Legolas - 20
Faramir - 19
Thorin - 21
Round 2 - Leader Board
Boromir - 40
Pippin - 40
Witch King - 40
Frodo - 36
Morgoth - 33
Merry - 24
Sam - 24
’omer - 23
Gandalf - 22
Thorin - 21
Aragorn - 20
Gimli - 20
Legolas - 20
The Mouth of Sauron - 20
Faramir - 19
Round 3
Boromir - 20
Pippin - 20
Witch King - 20
Frodo - 20
Morgoth - 20
Merry - 20
Sam - 20
’omer - 20
Gandalf - 20
Thorin - 20
Hey Cheesy, I PMed you about the Journal I'm writing. Could you respond?
And yet another 10 for Frodo please...
I have not received any PMs 
10 from Pippin.
10 from Pippin.
I was just wondering what Mithingal looked like, but I went ahead with it anyway.
Five to Merry and five to Pippin (yes, I'm sponsoring them ).
Five to Merry and five to Pippin (yes, I'm sponsoring them
).A smaller Minas Morgul/Tirith, with a large temple with a roof made from emeralds in the middle.
Ah... I imagined it as a kind of Mediterreanean city, with white walls and terracotta roofs. Should I change it? I haven't described the palace yet, though, so I'll be able to write that in the second part.
I don't mind. I have the second part of my thing almost done, which is pretty much all based in Mithingal.
Do you mean The Defence of Orthanc?
the second part of that, yeah.
Cool. 
Have you read mine yet?
Have you read mine yet?
Yeah. Its good 
10 from Pippin.
You're so mean to him! 
Seven to Pippin and three to Merry.
[First posted on the 26th of May, edited to change 'four' to 'three' on the 27th]
Seven to Pippin and three to Merry.
[First posted on the 26th of May, edited to change 'four' to 'three' on the 27th]
Ten to Frodo again please!
Ten to Pippin. The hobbits shall rise!
7 to Boromir, 3 from Pippin.
Seven to Pippin, three to Merry.
10 from Pippin
You have voted twice today, so; 72 from Merry.
Soz, 
Post deleted.
Post deleted.
Thank you 
10 from Pippin.
You're going to get tired of this but 10 for Frodo, please. Has he got to 40 yet?
Round 3 - 12 PCPs
Boromir - 27
Pippin - 6
Witch King - 20
Frodo - 40
Morgoth - 20
Merry - 28
Sam - 20
’omer - 20
Gandalf - 20
Thorin - 20
Boromir - 27
Pippin - 6
Witch King - 20
Frodo - 40
Morgoth - 20
Merry - 28
Sam - 20
’omer - 20
Gandalf - 20
Thorin - 20
6 from Pippin, and 4 to Morgoth.
5 to Morgoth, 5 to Boromir.
Game 2 Stuff
Round 0 of the Second Elimination Game will take place in 4 segments. The 5 winners of each segment will go through to Round 1, which will be played the same. The Fellowship do not go through to Round 1 Automatically.
Part 1 - 11 Hobbits, Including: Merry, Pippin, Bullroarer, Drogo Baggins, Sm’agol, D’agol and Bill the Pony. (11/11 Chosen)
Part 2 - 20 Elves, Including: Elrond, Arwen, Celeborn, Gil-Galad, Fingolfin and Thranduil. (20/20 Chosen)
Part 3 - 25 Humans, Including: Aragorn, Arathorn, Eldarion, Isildur, Theoden and Faramir. (15/25 Chosen)
Part 4 - 30 Baddies/Maiar, Including: Melkor, Sauron, Ungoliant, Gandalf, Radagast, Gothmog, Lurtz, Smaug and Ugluk. (0/30 Chosen)
I promise I will not do anything to Frodo, Merry or Pippin in Round 0 or 1
Game 2 Stuff
Round 0 of the Second Elimination Game will take place in 4 segments. The 5 winners of each segment will go through to Round 1, which will be played the same. The Fellowship do not go through to Round 1 Automatically.
Part 1 - 11 Hobbits, Including: Merry, Pippin, Bullroarer, Drogo Baggins, Sm’agol, D’agol and Bill the Pony. (11/11 Chosen)
Part 2 - 20 Elves, Including: Elrond, Arwen, Celeborn, Gil-Galad, Fingolfin and Thranduil. (20/20 Chosen)
Part 3 - 25 Humans, Including: Aragorn, Arathorn, Eldarion, Isildur, Theoden and Faramir. (15/25 Chosen)
Part 4 - 30 Baddies/Maiar, Including: Melkor, Sauron, Ungoliant, Gandalf, Radagast, Gothmog, Lurtz, Smaug and Ugluk. (0/30 Chosen)
I promise I will not do anything to Frodo, Merry or Pippin in Round 0 or 1
10 to Morgoth.
Can I try and revive this?
10 to Smeagol
I don't think I understand where this is at - is there a new game, or are we continuing the old one?
10 to Sauron! (okay, someone explain, please??)
I think its a new game...
thats why i put ten for good old poor Gollum
Why don't we just carry the old one on? We are 4 posts away from the end of this round. Gollum and Sauron are out, by the way. Basically, add points on to characters you like, take from ones you don't, and the characters with the most points after 20+ posts go through.
Boromir +8 (Through)
Morgoth +1 (Through)
Sam -1
