#4Is it north of an east-west line running through the Brandywine Bridge?

#5 Is it in Gondor?

#6 Is it water filled?

#7 Was it located south of an east-west line drawn through Isengard (or more specificly, the Tower of Orthanc)?

#8 Does it lie to the west of a north-south line through Osgiliath?

I thought we could guess up to twenty times.

#9 Is Stonewain Valley?

#10 Does it lie east of a north-south line through Erech?

#11 Is it the mountain, Starkhorn?

As I do not have a map of ME here with me at work, this is a total guess....is it the Emyn Muiel? (not sure if I spelled that right folks)

#12 You're really very, very close now, Grond, ... but still not there ... It is not the Standing Stone which lies between the Dimholt Woods and the Dark Door at Dunharrow I'm looking for.

Former answers:

#1 No, it is not alive.
#2 Yes, it is a place.
#3 No, it is not west of the Misty Mountains.
#4 No, it is not north of an East-West line running through Brandywine Bridge.
#5 I'll give everybody a hint: lands, I mean countries with borders aren't of any use to locate it. Ask relative, not absolute.
#6 No, it is not water filled.
#7 It is (still) located South of an East-West line through Isengard.
#8 Yes, it lies to the West of a North-South line through Osgiliath.
#9 No, it is not Stoneway Valley.
#10 You must have a very detailed map of ME, Grond. On my map it's neither east or west of a north-south line through Erech.
#11 No, it is not the mountain, Starkhorn.

And .. upon request: the original question for Terrijayne:

AGE: Third Age (presumably. This is a hint!)
AREA: Middle-earth
Eyespy with my little eye... something that starts with... S

(Grondy just added #11 to the list.)

#13 There you go astray, Grond. It is not the Stair of the Hold. But as I said before, you are very close. Remind my hint in the original question!

Former answers:

#1 No, it is not alive.
#2 Yes, it is a place.
#3 No, it is not west of the Misty Mountains.
#4 No, it is not north of an East-West line running through Brandywine Bridge.
#5 I'll give everybody a hint: lands, I mean countries with borders aren't of any use to locate it. Ask relative, not absolute.
#6 No, it is not water filled.
#7 It is (still) located South of an East-West line through Isengard.
#8 Yes, it lies to the West of a North-South line through Osgiliath.
#9 No, it is not Stoneway Valley.
#10 You must have a very detailed map of ME, Grond. On my map it's neither east or west of a north-south line through Erech.
#11 No, it is not the mountain, Starkhorn
#12 You're really very, very close now, Grond, ... but still not there ... It is not the Standing Stone which lies between the Dimholt Woods and the Dark Door at Dunharrow I'm looking for.

And .. upon request: the original question for Terrijayne:

AGE: Third Age (presumably. This is a hint!)
AREA: Middle-earth
Eyespy with my little eye... something that starts with... S

Is it the Stone of Erech?

Okay, sorry for the delay.

Age: Third
Location: The Shire
Eyespy with my little eye... something that starts with... S

1. No, not a Hobbit name.

1. No Hobbit's name.
2. Yes, it's a place.

1. No Hobbit's name.
2. Yes, it's a place.
3. No, not south of the Great East Road.

1. No Hobbit's name.
2. Yes, it's a place.
3. No, not south of the Great East Road.
4. No, it is not east of that north-south line drawn through the Three-Farthing Stone.

1. No Hobbit's name.
2. Yes, it's a place.
3. No, not south of the Great East Road.
4. No, it is not east of that north-south line drawn through the Three-Farthing Stone.
5. No, it is not Sandyman's Mill.

Very good. It is Sharkey's end, or "New Row" as it should be called. Your turn, Grodny!

#2 - It's not a plant, is it?

#3 Is it south of the Great East Road?

4. Does a river run through it?

The wording of that answer sends me in a different direction.

#5 Did someone sing to it in FOTR?

LOL. No, I think it's an old thing in the Old Forest, namely Old Man Willow.