I'm glad someone else jumps in Loss....lol
Well done Grondy, sorry I didn't get back to answer but had the dreaded D & V - the hospital where I work is rife with it ... now my smilie story of the last day so.........

lol...lol...lol...lol
Anyway, I'll have an A when Loss puts in a question.
Sorry I havn't posted a puzzle lately, but I'm here now

;
_ _ _ / _ _ _ _ / _ _ _ _ _ _ _ (3, 4, 7)
and with the guesses;
_ _ _ / _ I _ _ / _ A L _ _ _ _
No wrong guesses there......... 1
A for M
ayd (hey there), 1
I for Raffy and 1
L for Grondy

Nice to see you w
heeling t
his game, Loss! I would like a try wit
h the
Hs, please!

May I have an E dear Loss ?
I'd like Raffy's R please.
T H E / _ I _ E / _ A L _ E R _
No wrong guesses still!!!!
That's 1
A for M
ayd (hey there), 1
I and 1
H for Raffy, 1
L and 1
R for G
rondy, 3
E's for M
ellon and 1
T for Fionwe

Still not seeing the answer, so I'll guess an S please.
All I want for now is a N or two, please!
Slim pickings for right answers as there aren't many letters left
T H E / N I N E / _ A L _ E R S
That's 1
A for M
ayd, 1
I, 2
N's and 1
H for Raffy, 1
L, 1
S and 1
R for G
rondy, 3
E's for M
ellon and 1
T for Fionwe
but.......... no
F for Thorin or
D for Mellon or a
C for Fionwe but............. DO NOT PANIC!!! It's getting closer now........
The Nine Walkers - Good one Loss
So try:
_ _ _ _ _ _ / _ _ _ / _ _ _ _ _ / _ _ _ _ _ (four words of 6, 3, 5, and 5 letters length respectivly.)
May I start with an A this time sir Grondy ?
May I have a T then Grondy ?
Thanks Grondy.......
May I have an L or two please???
Then I'll try an I or two, please!
i'll try a guess:
the seconf word is The
the third word is white
the forth word is river
as for the first i have no idea.
so give me a c

Yes, we have two
Ds,
Is, and
Rs for Rafael; four
Es for Thorin; three
Hs and two
Ts for Mellon; and one
L for Loss.
So now it reads:
_ E H _ L D / T H E / _ H I T E / R I D E R

Sorry, nary an
A, a
C, nor a
G.

You must guess all of it or just one letter at a time Thorin; partial guesses aren't fair to the rest of the players and you actually guessed three letters that turn; I ignored all except your last one. Please think about being more considerate. - Thanks

Sir Grondy, my guess will be : Behold, the White Rider!
Sorry sir grondy. i wont do it again.
You got it
Rafael, your turn to make us the next puzzle.
A
nd towards it, I'd like a
n N or two, please.
Not really a problem Thorin.

HAPPY NEW YEAR DEAR FATHER

May I please have an
A ?
_ _ _ _ _ _/ _ _ _ _ /_ _ _/ _ _ _ _ a _ _ /_ _ _ _/_ _ _ _ _/_ _/_ _ a _/(6,4,3,7,4,5,2,4)=35
2
a's to Mellon
Happy new year eveyone!!!!!
Sorry Grondy, no
N!
Then may I please have an L or three.
Whoaaaaa!!! What a long guess!! But i'll have some e's please
_ _ L _ E _/ _ L _ _ /_ _ E/ _ _ _ E A _ _ /_ _ _ _/_ E L _ _/_ _/E _ A _/(6,4,3,7,4,5,2,4)=35
2A's to Mellon, 5E's to Thorin, 3L's to Grondy; means only 25 letters to go
N is a negative letter
we'uns wants some Rs, if you please.
I may as well ask for the H please, even though I don't have a clue to the solution.
My, my.........'tis a long puzzle..... but I shall guess an
F i
f you please sir Ra
ffy

I'mclose but some of the words don't quite spell out correctly, still I might be guessing wrongly.
Anyway; I'd like an M, please.
Congrats Sir Raffy, you have certainly got a toughy......... but I shall have a W or two???
S I L V E R/F L O W /T H E/ S T R E A M S/F R O M/_ E L OS/T O/E R A I/(6,4,3,7,4,5,2,4)=35
2 As + 4 Os + 3 Ts + 4 Ss to Mellon, 5 Es + 2 Is + 1 V to Thorin, 3 Ls + 4 Rs + 1 H + 2 Ms to Grondy, 2 Fs + 1 W to Loss; means only 1 letter to go
N is the only negative letter used in this wheel.
As far as I can see, the solution is a cooperation! Mellon got 13/35,10/35 to Sir Grondy, Thorin got 8/35 and Loss strikes in with 3/35.
I now know what it is, but as I had to cheat and searched for it I'll wait a day or two and give the rest of you a chance for it But I will provide a hint: It is a line in a poem.