Thread: Wheel of Tolkien
Planet Tolkien is archived and no longer updated, but the forums remain browseable. We have established a Telegram group for old and new visitors to stay connected and discuss all things Tolkien.<< [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23] [24] [25] [26] [27] [28] [29] [30] [31] [32] [33] [34] [35] [36] [37] [38] [39] [40] [41] [42] [43] [44] [45] [46] [47] [48] [49] [50] [51] [52] [53] [54] [55] [56] [57] [58] [59] [60] [61] [62] [63] [64] [65] [66] [67] [68] [69] [70] [71] [72] [73] [74] [75] [76] [77] [78] [79] [80] [81] [82] [83] [84] [85] [86] [87] [88] [89] [90] [91] [92] [93] [94] [95] [96] [97] [98] [99] [100] [101] [102] [103] [104] [105] [106] [107] [108] [109] [110] [111] [112] [113] [114] [115] [116] [117] [118] [119] [120] [121] [122] [123] [124] [125] [126] [127] [128] [129] [130] [131] [132] [133] [134] [135] [136] [137] [138] [139] [140] [141] [142] [143] [144] [145] [146] >>
Man, I suck at guessing...(at least it isn't 'hangman'!) I guess i will resort to an O
time for a M?
Yes, 
we have three As for Gimili; and three Es, three Is, and one M for Thinker.
So it now reads:
_ I _ / _ _ I _ I _ _ / _ E _ M / A _ A _ / _ A _ / _ E E _
Sorry,
nary a C, an O, nor a T in my puzzle.
we have three As for Gimili; and three Es, three Is, and one M for Thinker.So it now reads:
_ I _ / _ _ I _ I _ _ / _ E _ M / A _ A _ / _ A _ / _ E E _
Sorry,
nary a C, an O, nor a T in my puzzle.Wow, that was embarassing... Now, to break my bad guess streak, a Y!!
N?
Yes, we have three As for Gimili; and three Es, three Is, one M, and three Ns for Thinker.
So it now reads:
_ I _ / _ _ I _ I _ _ / _ E _ M / A _ A _ / _ A _ / _ E E _
Sorry, nary a C, an O, a T, nor a Y in my puzzle.
Bad luck Gimli, maybe you can guess it before Thinker fills in most of the rest of them.
we have three As for Gimili; and three Es, three Is, one M, and three Ns for Thinker.So it now reads:
_ I _ / _ _ I _ I _ _ / _ E _ M / A _ A _ / _ A _ / _ E E _
Sorry,
nary a C, an O, a T, nor a Y in my puzzle.Bad luck Gimli, maybe you can guess it before Thinker fills in most of the rest of them.
I'll guess for an H Grondy.
Yes, we have three As for Gimili; three Es, three Is, one M, and three Ns for Thinker; and three Hs for Thorin.
So it now reads:
H I _ / _ H I N I N _ / H E _ M / A _ A _ / _ A _ / _ E E N
Sorry, nary a C, an O, a T, nor a Y in my puzzle.
we have three As for Gimili; three Es, three Is, one M, and three Ns for Thinker; and three Hs for Thorin.So it now reads:
H I _ / _ H I N I N _ / H E _ M / A _ A _ / _ A _ / _ E E N
Sorry,
nary a C, an O, a T, nor a Y in my puzzle.A K...? (I think I'm on to something.... if I get a K)
Yes, we have three As for Gimili; three Es, three Is, one M, and three Ns for Thinker; and three Hs for Thorin.
So it still reads:
H I _ / _ H I N I N _ / H E _ M / A _ A _ / _ A _ / _ E E N
Sorry, nary a C, a K, an O, a T, nor a Y in my puzzle.
we have three As for Gimili; three Es, three Is, one M, and three Ns for Thinker; and three Hs for Thorin.So it still reads:
H I _ / _ H I N I N _ / H E _ M / A _ A _ / _ A _ / _ E E N
Sorry,
nary a C, a K, an O, a T, nor a Y in my puzzle.B?
Hmmmm.....I seem to have lost a post. I remember having asked for an S! Well, it doesn't matter, can i have a couple of Sessssssss please Grondy?
Yes, we have three As for Gimili; three Es, three Is, one M, and three Ns for Thinker; and three Hs and four Ss for Thorin.
So it still reads:
H I S / S H I N I N _ / H E _ M / A _ A _ / _ A S / S E E N
Sorry, nary a B, a C, a K, an O, a T, nor a Y in my puzzle.
No Thorin, I also couldn't find any previous guess of an S by you for this puzzle. So unless your dog or our server ate it, you probably figured it had an S or three and rather than giving someone else that big clue, you decided to hold back and guess a different letter until you figured out what one or two of the five remaining letters were.
we have three As for Gimili; three Es, three Is, one M, and three Ns for Thinker; and three Hs and four Ss for Thorin.So it still reads:
H I S / S H I N I N _ / H E _ M / A _ A _ / _ A S / S E E N
Sorry,
nary a B, a C, a K, an O, a T, nor a Y in my puzzle.No Thorin, I also couldn't find any previous guess of an S by you for this puzzle. So unless your dog or our server ate it, you probably figured it had an S or three and rather than giving someone else that big clue, you decided to hold back and guess a different letter until you figured out what one or two of the five remaining letters were.
What, no one wants to guess the answer because they don't want to pose the next question? Or have they just got bored with the game?
no one wants to guess the answer because they don't want to pose the next question? Or have they just got bored with the game? I almost have it. Can I have a Y?
No, Gimli, you still can't have a Y you tried to get on on 06 May and I wouldn't let you have one then either. 
Now, what letter did you really want to ask for? 
Yes, we have three As for Gimili; three Es, three Is, one M, and three Ns for Thinker; and three Hs and four Ss for Thorin.
So it still reads:
H I S / S H I N I N _ / H E _ M / A _ A _ / _ A S / S E E N
Sorry, nary a B, a C, a K, an O, a T, nor a Y in my puzzle.
Now, what letter did you really want to ask for? Yes,
we have three As for Gimili; three Es, three Is, one M, and three Ns for Thinker; and three Hs and four Ss for Thorin.So it still reads:
H I S / S H I N I N _ / H E _ M / A _ A _ / _ A S / S E E N
Sorry,
nary a B, a C, a K, an O, a T, nor a Y in my puzzle. Wow. I feel dumb........................... 
Fine I will go for an L! Aha!
I am only missing one word! Arrggh!
Fine I will go for an L! Aha!I am only missing one word! Arrggh!
Hit me up with a G, Grondy
might there be an F in there ?
His Shinning Helm Afar was seen
You all had good guesses this time, but Thorin has solved it (from Sam's rendition of a part of the lay called The Fall of Gil-galad, which he sang as they approached Weathertop).
So it is Thorin's turn.
So it is Thorin's turn.
Afar! Arghhh, thats the only word I was missing!!!
Anyway, I would like an A in the next puzzle.
Anyway, I would like an A in the next puzzle.
Yes! Before even writing the puzzle Gimli will get his A
So now:
_ _ _ _ _ /_ _ A _ _ / _ _ / _ _ _ _ _ _
Good Luck folks!
So now:
_ _ _ _ _ /_ _ A _ _ / _ _ / _ _ _ _ _ _
Good Luck folks!
Hehehehe! I got one right! Eat it! 
May I please have a load of Ls for starters?
So now:
_ _ _ L _ /_ _ A _ _ / _ _ / _ _ _ _ _ _
Good Luck folks!
So we noz have:
Gimli_man: 1 A
Grondy: 1 L
Next round of guessing please!
_ _ _ L _ /_ _ A _ _ / _ _ / _ _ _ _ _ _
Good Luck folks!
So we noz have:
Gimli_man: 1 A
Grondy: 1 L
Next round of guessing please!
i will guess an E?
May I please have an N or two kind sir?
Now, for an I!
Sorry about not posting a letter in my last post. I was caught up in the moment of breaking my losing streak!
Sorry about not posting a letter in my last post. I was caught up in the moment of breaking my losing streak!
So now:
_ I _ L I /_ _ A _ _ / _ _ / E _ E _ _ _
Good Luck folks!
So we noz have:
Gimli_man: 1 A, 2 Is
Grondy: 1 L
Thinker: 2 Es
Next round of guessing please!
_ I _ L I /_ _ A _ _ / _ _ / E _ E _ _ _
Good Luck folks!
So we noz have:
Gimli_man: 1 A, 2 Is
Grondy: 1 L
Thinker: 2 Es
Next round of guessing please!
I still need a ruling on my N from yesterday please; and instead of waiting, I'll go with a D today.
I will go for an S.
I will guess an O?
So now:
G I _ L I /_ _ A _ _ / O _ / E _ E _ O _
Good Luck folks!
So we now have:
Gimli_man: 1 A, 2 Is
Grondy: 1 L, 1G
Thinker: 2 Es, 2O
Sorry no N and S
Next round of guessing please!
G I _ L I /_ _ A _ _ / O _ / E _ E _ O _
Good Luck folks!
So we now have:
Gimli_man: 1 A, 2 Is
Grondy: 1 L, 1G
Thinker: 2 Es, 2O
Sorry no N and S
Next round of guessing please!
Well, seeing as how I was wrong with my last guess, I will ask for the obvious M, please.
Ahh, Grondy, you took my letter. So I will resort to an F.
is it Gimli Dwarf of Erebor ?
Thinker has got the correct answer! Congratulations!!!
Well, for Tinker's puzzle I would like an O.
first round
_ o _ _/ _ _/ _ _ _ _ _ _/ _ _ _/ _ o _ _ _/ _ _ _ _ _. 25 letters in 6 words
Two Os for Gimli.......
_ o _ _/ _ _/ _ _ _ _ _ _/ _ _ _/ _ o _ _ _/ _ _ _ _ _. 25 letters in 6 words
Two Os for Gimli.......
Any Tfor me Thinker?
Second round
_ o _ _/ _ _/ _ _ _ _ _ _/ t _ _/ _ o _ _ _/ _ _ _ _ _. 25 letters in 6 words
Two Os for Gimli.......
One T for Thorin....
_ o _ _/ _ _/ _ _ _ _ _ _/ t _ _/ _ o _ _ _/ _ _ _ _ _. 25 letters in 6 words
Two Os for Gimli.......
One T for Thorin....
Are there any Rs please.
An E please
Second round
_ o _ e/ _ _/ _ e _ _ _ _/ t _ e/ _ o r _ _/ _ _ e _ _. 25 letters in 6 words
Two Os for Gimli.......
One T for Thorin
Four Es for Gimli and One R for Grondy
_ o _ e/ _ _/ _ e _ _ _ _/ t _ e/ _ o r _ _/ _ _ e _ _. 25 letters in 6 words
Two Os for Gimli.......
One T for Thorin
Four Es for Gimli and One R for Grondy
Are there any Ls please?
Any Hs?
Third Round
H o _ e/ _ _/ _ e h _ _ _/ t h e/ _ o r l _/ _ h e _ _. 25 letters in 6 words
Two Os for Gimli.......
One T for Thorin
Four Es for Gimli and One R for Grondy
One L for Grondy and Four Hs for Gimli.....
H o _ e/ _ _/ _ e h _ _ _/ t h e/ _ o r l _/ _ h e _ _. 25 letters in 6 words
Two Os for Gimli.......
One T for Thorin
Four Es for Gimli and One R for Grondy
One L for Grondy and Four Hs for Gimli.....
Would there possibly be a W please?
Fourth Round
H o _ e/ _ _/ _ e h _ _ _/ t h e/ w o r l _/ _ h e _ _. 25 letters in 6 words
Two Os for Gimli.......
One T for Thorin
Four Es for Gimli and One R for Grondy
One L for Grondy and Four Hs for Gimli.....
One W for Grondy
H o _ e/ _ _/ _ e h _ _ _/ t h e/ w o r l _/ _ h e _ _. 25 letters in 6 words
Two Os for Gimli.......
One T for Thorin
Four Es for Gimli and One R for Grondy
One L for Grondy and Four Hs for Gimli.....
One W for Grondy
